Seriously mate have a look at yourself and get educated. Keep shit like that up and we have the disaster of the East coast to look forward to.
I'm the first to say I love my fish and fishing. Do a lot of spearing too. As such we get to CHOOSE the fish we kill. Leave these old blokes alone and re-think being an utter twat.
How can you comment when your picture is of a totally protected cod held up by the gills with a big smile on your face. Bet it lived eh? And no sayin it was caught in deep water and couldnt sink it and you feel sad about it.
Thanks for your opinions champ. I allways operate within leagal requirments set by dep fisheries, from what i have seen fish stocks down that way are pretty healthy.
Im not sure what this "spero rep" you talk of is all about, but from your general negativity i think im starting to form my on opinion!
Would I have had a different opinion if free diving?
No not really.
My opinion sure would have been different without your smart ass comment of "fillets in the freezer bewdy"
Perhaps something like,
Yep man been on my bucket list for a while and got this boy with a sure shot. Heaps here and well, we all get a one off eh?
Next one I'll shoot with a camera!
No I'm not a Greenie, far from it but there ARE spieces out there that just too easily explioted and anyone who's seen these lads underwater know they are super inquisitive and really...........dumb as dogshit for any spearo.
I asked if, and gave you a chance for a reply that showed you as an educated diver who knew the age and easily explioted nature of this fish (Damn mate its likely older than you) but you showed you are not.
As for my Avitar you are partly correct. The Malabar cod is NOT a protected species but the one in shot was well over size. As it was caught in 80m of water and even with venting and using my anchor as a makeshift release wieght plus 20 mins of towing we could not revive the fish.
It was then that some shots were taken and the fish was left to drift away.
Yes I am happy to justify that shot buddy.
Such a shame so many don't or cant.
Ps// If you have Kids let them read the full trancript this post and then justify yourself to them. See how that goes.
Some shoot with camera. Rifles. Spearguns. Bows. Ect. Would have hammered. Must admit I leave them alone. But everyone different and sounds like it's not going to waste:):).not getting involved top photo.
No POTM there..If your having a bad day and nothing else on the radar and you are happy eating shit fish then take one... These big old Bluey's follow you around like they are your pets..easy to kill..shame that
This ole chesnut again. Personal opinion, personal ethics are just that - you can surely voice your opinion but Matt is within the rules and there's nothing wrong with that. You can take offence to the way he has posted it and I can take offence to the way you have written your response to him.
It is all a matter of opinion and in Matt's opinion, taking one is fine and within the law and there is nothing wrong with that.
Ok so it seems that opinions vary widely as expected and as Adam noted Matt did nothing wrong. True, never once said he did.
I must ask why it is that the only post that seems acceptable is "Great fish man Beauty!!"
I love to check out the posts here as we all do and love some of the comments, amazing fish and freak catches.
HOWEVER!!
WHY is it that if you see something you DONT like you are expected to turn a blind eye and make no comment?
We are a community of fishing/diving lovers are we not?
Is the only post possible one that ONLY pats the dude on the back?
Lets make sure that we all can do the things we love for a contunued time through to the next generation.
As such I aired MY OPINION towards Matt's Photo.
The reponse was what it was, and I felt that Matt lost the point of my simple question of him.
I will state again the thing that Pisses me and many likeminded divers off so much.
This spieces. Plain and simple. It's a damn tragedy to see them shot. So slow to mature, so old when they change sex so dopey for the recless Spearo.
Matt, your not sure about the "spearo rep" because your exactly the reason we have it. Poor judgement and no education about some fish.
Cruzy, took your OPINION on board and if you want you can get the whole story here on this site under "serious Malaber cod" hope that will help you out.
Jonny, too true we all have different ways we go about our fishing and hunting. Do you have a trophy of your neibours bull on your wall? No, but in spearing terms Matt has.
Peel & Rick, nicely constructed and well thought out arguements lads pat yourselves on the back.
Lastly Adam,
As admin mate I understand you dont want too much abusive tone or language on site but please take on board that we all indeed have our opinions and when aired that can make guys look into the post and maybe rethink some practises or just have a vent as we all should be able.
I come on this website to see photos of people going fishing and catching fish.
If you start yelling at people who are trying to share their fishing experiences with us, then they won't come on this forum and post photos anymore.
He didn't do anything wrong. If you want to see a maximum size limit on Blue Groper then mabye you should bring it up in a separate post or talk to someone in the Fisheries department.
I'm not a big fan of spearing big Blues, (and I spear) but no laws broken and up to the individual. Easier if the authorities put an end to this topic but we also don't want everything banned. Keep up the good work Mandurah Matt as it takes a bit of ticker to dive our coast these days.
Nice fish mate. Shoot at will I reckon if you are going to eat it and it's within the laws. It's better than hooking up to a massive groper and dragging it up to the top just so you can confirm what you already thought you had on your line then watching it float off. I've pulled up a massive groper (approx 30kgs at gnarloo) and use ten 32 ounce sinkers to get it back down out.
All you do by ramming YOUR OPINION down peoples throats and belittling them is end up looking like a flog.
I have shot big blues in the past however, I wouldn't again if the opportunity presented itself, my choice only. As we all know you are allowed to. To start roasting someone because of the way a reply has been interpreted and not being up to the standard that YOU require is a load of crap in MY OPINION.
Your point could have been made far better as mentioned in some of the posts above with out getting crew offside.
Keep the posts up Matt.
Glad to see. Obvious he was happy with his catch. And wanted to share. Wasn't wasted( food).mandurah Matt was shot down .20 kg plus dhues older:):). Big blues are easy on scuba . Compared to free dive . But I would have thought green ones where main breeders .( females). Before they change sex. ???? Glad to see his post still up. Big fox fish and black ass prob same age if not older as big blue. They are very friendly underwater. Agree. See all points. Fishing site .
Spot on alright to Dtrain! Easy to implement and has been in place for cod spiecies etc for ages.
A little more difficult for anglers taking these as the catch often kills them, but just like cod no point targeting them then and as much as it seems a waste they must go back. TOP post Dtrain.
Well done too in a wierd way Boydy as you have pointed out you leave them too, Great!
Oh and lads I truely love that I have seen both pos and neg posts. Lads are thinking about it and that is bloody brilliant.
Call me what ever you like too I dont give a flying F%$K as long as I'm allowed to give an opinion I'll do so and I hope some of you will rethink spearing one next time it comes up for a kiss.
Let it go mate. Matt did nothing wrong. Pretty impressive catch. And it didn't go to waste. Go find someone who kept a 40cm+ Black Bream and bash them for a little while. Or get off your computer and go fishing to ease that tension a bit. Works for me
Hi MandurahMat, not your post that need deleating, I used to spear a lot, still do on ocasion. I dont spear the big ones anny more, but good on you. The odd trophy fish and photo I like to see. At the moment I am copping flack from a couple of vegans because I eat meat, and fish. I dont believe in forcing my opinion on vegans, and don't like them trying to convince me I am a bad person cause I eat meat. Guess we will always get keyboard worriers ,tall poppie syndrome, " I am holier than thou" people. I would be happy to have a beer with you, ignore or block the wanna be god. Good luck with your next fishing trip.
MullaMaster
Posts: 17
Date Joined: 26/05/15
Ever heard of
Ever heard of Blueback...
Just joking:)
kirky79
Posts: 1354
Date Joined: 13/01/12
That's a bruiser. Well done
That's a bruiser. Well done
Hutch
Posts: 2221
Date Joined: 21/04/13
Ripper
Ripper
SQUIDDLY
Posts: 48
Date Joined: 22/12/13
MMM ok but wait.
Ok so thats a lovely 30 yr old+ blue you have there and a hooka in the background?
Please tell me it was a photo and release deal not speared and not shot in one of the worst ways imagined.
Gives us spearo's such a shit rep man.
Remember, in Bunbury;
LBS=KGS and never actually weigh your fish.
Just guess away!!!!
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
.
.
Bewdey Fellaz
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
.
.
Bewdey Fellaz
SQUIDDLY
Posts: 48
Date Joined: 22/12/13
GOOD ON YA!!
What a champ mate!
Be able to show your kids the photos eh?
Yep, only photos.
Seriously mate have a look at yourself and get educated. Keep shit like that up and we have the disaster of the East coast to look forward to.
I'm the first to say I love my fish and fishing. Do a lot of spearing too. As such we get to CHOOSE the fish we kill. Leave these old blokes alone and re-think being an utter twat.
Remember, in Bunbury;
LBS=KGS and never actually weigh your fish.
Just guess away!!!!
cruzy111
Posts: 274
Date Joined: 08/10/13
Good on ya Squiddly.
How can you comment when your picture is of a totally protected cod held up by the gills with a big smile on your face. Bet it lived eh? And no sayin it was caught in deep water and couldnt sink it and you feel sad about it.
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
Thanks for your opinions
Thanks for your opinions champ. I allways operate within leagal requirments set by dep fisheries, from what i have seen fish stocks down that way are pretty healthy.
Im not sure what this "spero rep" you talk of is all about, but from your general negativity i think im starting to form my on opinion!
Bewdey Fellaz
big john
Posts: 8751
Date Joined: 20/07/06
.
WA based manufacturer and supplier of premium leadhead jigs, fligs, bucktail jigs, 'bulletproof' soft plastic jig heads and XOS bullet jig heads.
Jigs available online in my web store!
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
.
.
Bewdey Fellaz
SQUIDDLY
Posts: 48
Date Joined: 22/12/13
Hi Again.
Would I have had a different opinion if free diving?
No not really.
My opinion sure would have been different without your smart ass comment of "fillets in the freezer bewdy"
Perhaps something like,
Yep man been on my bucket list for a while and got this boy with a sure shot. Heaps here and well, we all get a one off eh?
Next one I'll shoot with a camera!
No I'm not a Greenie, far from it but there ARE spieces out there that just too easily explioted and anyone who's seen these lads underwater know they are super inquisitive and really...........dumb as dogshit for any spearo.
I asked if, and gave you a chance for a reply that showed you as an educated diver who knew the age and easily explioted nature of this fish (Damn mate its likely older than you) but you showed you are not.
As for my Avitar you are partly correct. The Malabar cod is NOT a protected species but the one in shot was well over size. As it was caught in 80m of water and even with venting and using my anchor as a makeshift release wieght plus 20 mins of towing we could not revive the fish.
It was then that some shots were taken and the fish was left to drift away.
Yes I am happy to justify that shot buddy.
Such a shame so many don't or cant.
Ps// If you have Kids let them read the full trancript this post and then justify yourself to them. See how that goes.
Later Matt.
Remember, in Bunbury;
LBS=KGS and never actually weigh your fish.
Just guess away!!!!
little johnny
Posts: 5360
Date Joined: 04/12/11
Top fish
Some shoot with camera. Rifles. Spearguns. Bows. Ect. Would have hammered. Must admit I leave them alone. But everyone different and sounds like it's not going to waste:):).not getting involved top photo.
out wide
Posts: 1535
Date Joined: 30/12/08
No POTM there..If your
No POTM there..If your having a bad day and nothing else on the radar and you are happy eating shit fish then take one... These big old Bluey's follow you around like they are your pets..easy to kill..shame that
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
.
.
Bewdey Fellaz
PEEL 166
Posts: 83
Date Joined: 19/04/09
top fish Matt well done..
I have never read such rubbish from over opinionated key board warrior's ! No rules broken . & a few feeds for later on in the freezer.
Rick
Posts: 1113
Date Joined: 22/12/06
Agree
Nice fish mate, ignore the tossers
PGFC Member
Adam Gallash
Posts: 15647
Date Joined: 29/11/05
Arrrgh
This ole chesnut again. Personal opinion, personal ethics are just that - you can surely voice your opinion but Matt is within the rules and there's nothing wrong with that. You can take offence to the way he has posted it and I can take offence to the way you have written your response to him.
It is all a matter of opinion and in Matt's opinion, taking one is fine and within the law and there is nothing wrong with that.
Site Admin - Just ask if you need assistance
Lastchance
Posts: 1273
Date Joined: 02/02/09
I reckon good on you for just
I reckon good on you for just getting into the water down there! Phark that!
SQUIDDLY
Posts: 48
Date Joined: 22/12/13
Well, one last post on it all.
Ok so it seems that opinions vary widely as expected and as Adam noted Matt did nothing wrong. True, never once said he did.
I must ask why it is that the only post that seems acceptable is "Great fish man Beauty!!"
I love to check out the posts here as we all do and love some of the comments, amazing fish and freak catches.
HOWEVER!!
WHY is it that if you see something you DONT like you are expected to turn a blind eye and make no comment?
We are a community of fishing/diving lovers are we not?
Is the only post possible one that ONLY pats the dude on the back?
Lets make sure that we all can do the things we love for a contunued time through to the next generation.
As such I aired MY OPINION towards Matt's Photo.
The reponse was what it was, and I felt that Matt lost the point of my simple question of him.
I will state again the thing that Pisses me and many likeminded divers off so much.
This spieces. Plain and simple. It's a damn tragedy to see them shot. So slow to mature, so old when they change sex so dopey for the recless Spearo.
Matt, your not sure about the "spearo rep" because your exactly the reason we have it. Poor judgement and no education about some fish.
Cruzy, took your OPINION on board and if you want you can get the whole story here on this site under "serious Malaber cod" hope that will help you out.
Jonny, too true we all have different ways we go about our fishing and hunting. Do you have a trophy of your neibours bull on your wall? No, but in spearing terms Matt has.
Peel & Rick, nicely constructed and well thought out arguements lads pat yourselves on the back.
Lastly Adam,
As admin mate I understand you dont want too much abusive tone or language on site but please take on board that we all indeed have our opinions and when aired that can make guys look into the post and maybe rethink some practises or just have a vent as we all should be able.
Remember, in Bunbury;
LBS=KGS and never actually weigh your fish.
Just guess away!!!!
Lastchance
Posts: 1273
Date Joined: 02/02/09
Well said
Well said
DTrain
Posts: 486
Date Joined: 10/02/12
I come on this website to see
I come on this website to see photos of people going fishing and catching fish.
If you start yelling at people who are trying to share their fishing experiences with us, then they won't come on this forum and post photos anymore.
He didn't do anything wrong. If you want to see a maximum size limit on Blue Groper then mabye you should bring it up in a separate post or talk to someone in the Fisheries department.
Adam Gallash
Posts: 15647
Date Joined: 29/11/05
zing
Dtrain, absolutely spot on.
Site Admin - Just ask if you need assistance
kirky79
Posts: 1354
Date Joined: 13/01/12
+1
Rick
Posts: 1113
Date Joined: 22/12/06
Constuctive !
Squiddly, Im sure your 29 posts on here, are a wealth of information for us all
Just my opinion
PGFC Member
Chinbald
Posts: 317
Date Joined: 21/02/09
Im with D Train
I'm not a big fan of spearing big Blues, (and I spear) but no laws broken and up to the individual. Easier if the authorities put an end to this topic but we also don't want everything banned. Keep up the good work Mandurah Matt as it takes a bit of ticker to dive our coast these days.
eziliving
Posts: 875
Date Joined: 30/12/09
Nice fish mate. Shoot at
Nice fish mate. Shoot at will I reckon if you are going to eat it and it's within the laws. It's better than hooking up to a massive groper and dragging it up to the top just so you can confirm what you already thought you had on your line then watching it float off. I've pulled up a massive groper (approx 30kgs at gnarloo) and use ten 32 ounce sinkers to get it back down out.
Get busy living, or get busy dying!
Boydy
Posts: 623
Date Joined: 26/09/12
SQUIDDLY
All you do by ramming YOUR OPINION down peoples throats and belittling them is end up looking like a flog.
I have shot big blues in the past however, I wouldn't again if the opportunity presented itself, my choice only. As we all know you are allowed to. To start roasting someone because of the way a reply has been interpreted and not being up to the standard that YOU require is a load of crap in MY OPINION.
Your point could have been made far better as mentioned in some of the posts above with out getting crew offside.
Keep the posts up Matt.
little johnny
Posts: 5360
Date Joined: 04/12/11
Good onya Adam
Glad to see. Obvious he was happy with his catch. And wanted to share. Wasn't wasted( food).mandurah Matt was shot down .20 kg plus dhues older:):). Big blues are easy on scuba . Compared to free dive . But I would have thought green ones where main breeders .( females). Before they change sex. ???? Glad to see his post still up. Big fox fish and black ass prob same age if not older as big blue. They are very friendly underwater. Agree. See all points. Fishing site .
SQUIDDLY
Posts: 48
Date Joined: 22/12/13
Such a healthy post this has become! Hasn't it?
Spot on alright to Dtrain! Easy to implement and has been in place for cod spiecies etc for ages.
A little more difficult for anglers taking these as the catch often kills them, but just like cod no point targeting them then and as much as it seems a waste they must go back. TOP post Dtrain.
Well done too in a wierd way Boydy as you have pointed out you leave them too, Great!
Oh and lads I truely love that I have seen both pos and neg posts. Lads are thinking about it and that is bloody brilliant.
Call me what ever you like too I dont give a flying F%$K as long as I'm allowed to give an opinion I'll do so and I hope some of you will rethink spearing one next time it comes up for a kiss.
Remember, in Bunbury;
LBS=KGS and never actually weigh your fish.
Just guess away!!!!
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
.
.
Bewdey Fellaz
sea-kem
Posts: 15002
Date Joined: 30/11/09
Good fish yes, POTM no. Not
Good fish yes, POTM no. Not buying into the other crap on this thread.
Love the West!
MandurahMatt
Posts: 613
Date Joined: 18/09/13
.
.
Bewdey Fellaz
SQUIDDLY
Posts: 48
Date Joined: 22/12/13
Wow Matt way to go.
Thanks for letting all see you as just the type of guy you are. Such calm and reasoned posts.
No wonder you want the post deleted mate.
Remember, in Bunbury;
LBS=KGS and never actually weigh your fish.
Just guess away!!!!
tadpole
Posts: 387
Date Joined: 28/01/13
Let it go mate. Matt did
Let it go mate. Matt did nothing wrong. Pretty impressive catch. And it didn't go to waste. Go find someone who kept a 40cm+ Black Bream and bash them for a little while. Or get off your computer and go fishing to ease that tension a bit. Works for me
marrisy
Posts: 202
Date Joined: 08/09/11
not your post
Hi MandurahMat, not your post that need deleating, I used to spear a lot, still do on ocasion. I dont spear the big ones anny more, but good on you. The odd trophy fish and photo I like to see. At the moment I am copping flack from a couple of vegans because I eat meat, and fish. I dont believe in forcing my opinion on vegans, and don't like them trying to convince me I am a bad person cause I eat meat. Guess we will always get keyboard worriers ,tall poppie syndrome, " I am holier than thou" people. I would be happy to have a beer with you, ignore or block the wanna be god. Good luck with your next fishing trip.
regards Marrisy.