Hillarys Boat Show - Good Bad and Ugly Boat Report

At the boat show at Hillarys today, gotta say it was small but I love boats so always enjoyable checking out other boats......good, compromised, bad and ugly.

GOOD

28 ft Fury dual console.I don't like bow riders, but man, I could live with this one. A beautifully built boat with some cool features, would need several tweeks to make it useable for me but I could own that boat. $250-300k is the compromise......may need to win lotto......

COMPROMISED

Regulator 23 ft CC. Bloody awesome 24 degree hull, would ride brilliantly in chop, but talk about unstable! I stepped on the gunwhale and it moved over 15 degrees.....two blokes on one side and it was 20 degrees. You would get out to your fishig spot bloody quick in this boat, but then turn around and go home to get a proper fishing boat that did not flop all over the place.....also, where the seat mounts it looked like there were stress cracks in the fibreglass on a new boat....$200k for a 23 ft CC.......pass.

BAD

The plethora of cheap and nasty ali boats with huge reverse chines that would slap like biatch in chop.....price tags suggest they come with a happy ending every night for a year......

UGLY....and worse than BAD

Don't know if this was a joke (I could not stop laughing.....), but this thing (I think it was a boat) was "pop" rivited and glued together and looked to be made of 2 mm galv sheet (I assume it was ali but it was very thin and flimsy....truly scary heading out past the 3 mile in this thing. Is this for real, it looked like a set prop?

The moral of the story....all boats are a compromise, but after seeing a heap of different boats......I am very happy with my Boston Whaler Conquest 235, and would not swap it with anything else....maybe a Fury if I had unlimited coin......

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

Image Upload: 

Posts: 5981

Date Joined: 17/06/10

Bow rider

Sun, 2016-04-10 17:03

IMO just one good way taken the wrong way and you have yourself a whole lot of water in the front, yes I know they have good drainage holes to clear the water.

However I saw one (don't know the make) up at Exmouth some years back between the point and the islands that had taken a bad surprise wave over the bow and it was in big trouble as the water could not be cleared before the next wave hit it. For a few moments/minutes he was in some real trouble until the water level receded some.

Have I been in one no is my comment valid on one encounter probably not, but it is the only up close observation I have had of the design.

JohnF's picture

Posts: 2836

Date Joined: 07/07/10

that is exactly why I dont

Sun, 2016-04-10 17:07

that is exactly why I dont like bowriders...but the Fury was SOOOOOOO pretty.

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

scano's picture

Posts: 1247

Date Joined: 31/05/07

Yes I agree completely John

Sun, 2016-04-10 17:21

 The 28 foot fury presented really well and the finish on it was top shelf. I was also impressed at the single 400hp verado strapped to the back of a rib, on the same floating platform as the fury.

having just recently changed tinnie boats myself I get what you mean about some cheap and nasties being out there. I ended up with a side console 465 horizon easy fisher pro. The Quintrex boats are finished off a little nicer but come with the large price tag to match the name. 

 

Scano

____________________________________________________________________________

 

 

avatinni's picture

Posts: 141

Date Joined: 06/06/10

 Just a quick question guys

Sun, 2016-04-10 17:25

 Just a quick question guys what would the difference between a bowrider and a centre / side Console be they are all open at the front. 

pricey10's picture

Posts: 486

Date Joined: 07/01/12

 bow rider would be ok in a

Sun, 2016-04-10 17:31

 bow rider would be ok in a big nice riding boat. But traditionally the front of the boat is the worst place to be when travelling.

People still love buying shit quality alloy boats I geuss they have never been in a quality boat

____________________________________________________________________________

Karratha. WA

Ben85's picture

Posts: 442

Date Joined: 20/11/11

 Some seriously dodgy boats

Sun, 2016-04-10 18:24

 Some seriously dodgy boats there this year including a lot of no name brands which I'm very surprised there is a market for. Standout boats for me were westerberg and another custom 720 plate boat. cant believe how expensive boats are becoming with most boats presenting very little value for money.

Posts: 46

Date Joined: 07/07/14

Westerbergs Boat

Mon, 2016-04-11 09:05

 Went back a few times to the Westerberg boats - like the rugged build and deck space. On a solid trailer too.

 

If only.............................................

 

 

z00m's picture

Posts: 1086

Date Joined: 10/05/14

Rivets

Sun, 2016-04-10 18:42

  Not to be flippant but they have been riveting together aircraft (including the fuel tanks) for more than half a century. Those G3 boats are part of Yamaha Marine.

As for the bow rider thing, I own a Dual Console so I guess I am biased. A traditional ally bow rider is not the same as a modern fibreglass dual console. Mine is only 21.5ft (compared to the 28ft of the Fury!!) but is a very dry riding boat. I don't go out fishing in extreme conditions but the SW chop can be a drag when it gets to 2 feet and you want to go south, however my boat stays mostly dry. The self draining deck would cover most situations I'll find myself in. The modern boats have an optional cover to fit over the front lounge so this would shed a lot of water if you needed to hit the massive swells for some reason. The layout and many uses of these style boats is why every leisure boat manufacturer has a Dual Console in their US range.

 

JohnF's picture

Posts: 2836

Date Joined: 07/07/10

I am honestly interested to

Sun, 2016-04-10 19:14

I am honestly interested to hear about the G3 rivet boats......they looked like something out of the Flintstones to be honest, but fair comment about airplanes....if Yammie are involved, they must be OK but they sure look horrible....

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

z00m's picture

Posts: 1086

Date Joined: 10/05/14

G3

Sun, 2016-04-10 21:12

 www.g3boats.com

Says on their about page they're a 'Yamaha Marine Company' whatever that means. I think the boat you showed a pic of was in the Angler series. There is an aussue page as well. Just add the .au.

Looked like site sponsor JetPower would have been showing them at the show?

sea-kem's picture

Posts: 14972

Date Joined: 30/11/09

 I'm not convinced re the

Sun, 2016-04-10 19:31

 I'm not convinced re the rivet boats, but then a gain that's how the olders one's were built including ships. I guess they've been engineered to cop a hammering but not my cup of tea. Welding is far more superior and quicker. As far as planes are concerned they were never designed to be slapped around in a 2.4m swell 

____________________________________________________________________________

Love the West!

Jason P's picture

Posts: 521

Date Joined: 16/02/13

 The Titanic had a rivet

Sun, 2016-04-10 19:36

 The Titanic had a rivet failure and we all know how that ended.

Aircraft rivets are supposed to be replaced every so many hours, I can't see that happening on a boat.

____________________________________________________________________________

 DM306

z00m's picture

Posts: 1086

Date Joined: 10/05/14

Iceberg

Sun, 2016-04-10 21:19

Shouldn't be too many icebergs on the 3 mile or in the river! 

Jason P's picture

Posts: 521

Date Joined: 16/02/13

 

Mon, 2016-04-11 13:07

 

____________________________________________________________________________

 DM306

z00m's picture

Posts: 1086

Date Joined: 10/05/14

Turbulence

Sun, 2016-04-10 21:21

Turbulence is way worse given the bending forces a plane has to endure. A plane is also used all day every day and undergoes pressurisation every trip. 

sea-kem's picture

Posts: 14972

Date Joined: 30/11/09

 yeah the metalurgy involved

Sun, 2016-04-10 21:26

 yeah the metalurgy involved in planes is insane. Tempering of the wings etc. I know commercial jets   are meant to have scheduled stress testing etc and it's quite a process from what I've read.

____________________________________________________________________________

Love the West!

Posts: 5796

Date Joined: 18/01/12

rivets

Mon, 2016-04-11 09:14

 Rivetting is used on thinner material because its stronger

Spreads the load where a weld would be subject to cracking

____________________________________________________________________________

 Give a man a mask, and he'll show you his true face...

 

 

The older you get the more you realize that no one has a f++king clue what they're doing.

Everyone's just winging it.

 

sea-kem's picture

Posts: 14972

Date Joined: 30/11/09

 And major distortion.

Mon, 2016-04-11 09:26

 And major distortion.

____________________________________________________________________________

Love the West!

z00m's picture

Posts: 1086

Date Joined: 10/05/14

Factory tour

Mon, 2016-04-11 09:57

There is a good factory tour video on the US web site that shows some of the attention to detail. They briefly mention the rivet idea but don't elaborate on why theirs are pretty much the only riveted boat I've seen in the rec market. 

DBZ's picture

Posts: 102

Date Joined: 05/02/11

Cheers for the write up John,

Mon, 2016-04-11 10:12

Cheers for the write up John, I didnt get a chance to head down there as prep work for 10 days at Abrolhos next week was in full swing over the weekend

 

Regarding the Regulators, I think you should take a run in one to see how they really go. A friend of mine has one on the east coast and they are absolute offshore weapons. We did a run in some fairly sloppy conditions off Sydney (25knt wind and 2.5m seas working against each other) and didnt have to come under 25knots - it was very impressive even compared to the plenty of Bostons I've run in. We landed a nice 180kg Blue on 37kg and a big fella fought a lot of the fight on the gunnel where stability was no issue at all.

 

Ive had a good look at the boats since then and am looking at getting a 23 in Perth. The length, volume and weight of the 23 is comparable to a 25 boston but fuel economy blows it away and price is sharper at last check

 

Dont take my word for it though, David Lockwood (respected independant boating Journo) has done a review on boatsales which goes into plenty of detail.

 

Be happy to take you for a run when my boat arrives!

JohnF's picture

Posts: 2836

Date Joined: 07/07/10

Don't get me wrong, a

Mon, 2016-04-11 10:59

Don't get me wrong, a Regulator will piss all over a Boston Whaler any day of the week in heavy chop, the hull has a fine entry point, steep deadrise and would be extremely smooth riding. But compromises are compromises, and a 24 degree dead rise compromises stability at rest...period. As for price, you are probably right.....$200k for that Regulator is good value compared with $110k for some of the tinnies with a flash paint job....

Its just what compromise you are most happy with. If it is blasting around in heavy chop, the Regulator looks like a beast. However, a centre console in Perth winter and an unstable platform at rest....not for me. And putting a hard top on a 24 degree dead rise hull results in further complications with ride and stability based on my experience.

I have been in a few 24 degree dead rise boats...they all had the same great points and the same bad downsides.

Choose your poison.

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

damo6230's picture

Posts: 2029

Date Joined: 07/06/08

24 degree deadrise

Wed, 2016-04-13 15:20

My Noble has a 24 degree deadrise and double reverse chines and is very stable at rest; very stable such that you can walk around the gunnels no problem (I have no rails).
No downsides for me!!
Not all boats with 24 deadrise are sloppy! 100% of people who ride in the boat comment on the soft ride; and its not a glass boat.
As you said all boats are a comprimise so buy what you want the boat to do for you and your fishing style.
Going to be hard buying another boat after the Noble.
Yes I have been in plenty of glass boats that cracked the spine!

Posts: 5796

Date Joined: 18/01/12

 check if that is "effective

Thu, 2016-04-14 21:46

 check if that is "effective deadrise" or just local, looking at Nobles website and measuring the picture they show, it is 24 local, but only 19 effective.
Effective deadrise is measured between the the keel and the outer point of the chine, not the inner.
That is why your boat is quite stable.

Last time I went to the Hillarys Boat Show I did a little experiment and measured the deadrise (local and estimated effective) on a few of the mainly plate boats whose salesmen I talked to.
All except maybe Westerberg exaggerated so that it didnt even match local deadrise (keel to inner chine) let alone effective deadrise.
My Cruisecraft measures 21 deg local and around 20 effective.

____________________________________________________________________________

 Give a man a mask, and he'll show you his true face...

 

 

The older you get the more you realize that no one has a f++king clue what they're doing.

Everyone's just winging it.

 

epic restos and marine's picture

Posts: 226

Date Joined: 22/06/15

 buy the sounds of it was a

Mon, 2016-04-11 12:11

 buy the sounds of it was a good showing mmmmmm was going to take two of my boats but have never been keen on this show (can see why) although maybe i should have 

____________________________________________________________________________

Lastchance's picture

Posts: 1273

Date Joined: 02/02/09

I was surprised a number of

Mon, 2016-04-11 12:13

I was surprised a number of years ago when at the boat show looking to buy a new boat. I was looking to replace my 8m Patriot that had been written off. I looked at the Aussie/yank glass boats and hadnt made a decision when I walked passed a Tinny with a flash paint job and was offered a test run. I initially declined, but the lure of free beer soon saw me and 3 others heading out for a spin. I was anticipating a predictably shit trip being ally, getting bashed around as it was fairly choppy. To my surprise it rode really well, trim up/down and at different speeds. The fit out was great bla bla bla. I ended up buying one a week later. Basically, not all boats are what they seem and it goes to show that the only way to find out is to give it a go. It does occaisionally bang a bit when I need to push it a bit when rough for whatever reason, but no worse than a 255 Conquest (Keep that 235 mate, they are a great boat compared to the 255!). Its the least worse riding Ally Ive been on! Still have it 7 years later here in Darwin with nearly 2000 hours on the motor, hasnt missed a beat. Its one of the only good decisions Ive made drinking beer!
Daisy

DBZ's picture

Posts: 102

Date Joined: 05/02/11

Yeah a lot of our

Mon, 2016-04-11 12:29

Yeah a lot of our fishing/diving is done well offshore (40+ miles) so the ride underway is top of the list for me. My current boat is a blackwatch 25 which has done a good job for similar stuff but the stability at rest was a bit of an issue there. Compared to the BW the Reg seemed a lot more stable, probably because of the extra width and weight

 

The other big decider for me was the fuel economy which is about 35% better compared to the 25 boston outrage. With the amount of fishing I (and you) do that adds up pretty quick

 

 

 

Humpback's picture

Posts: 103

Date Joined: 15/01/15

boat show

Mon, 2016-04-11 17:25

 Thanks for the boat show summary John. Like most others have said glad i didnt make the effort to go now.

I find myself agreeing with both you and DBZ. I used to own a 235 conquest and thought long and hard before upgrading. I do a lot of long running offshore good and bad conditions and was concerned about centre console in winter or windy condition. However in the new 25 outrage very dry very comfy ride compared to mates that try to keep up in a whitely and haines hunter. The perspex side curtains are a real winner keeping all crew very dry and easy to put up and down. When drift fishing much prefer the extra space especially the deep drop with electrics nice to spread out and cover more ground imo.(heading up to coral bay in June and to be able to quickly lead fish around the boat also very easy)

DBZ:In regards to economy of the outrage i went slighly bigger on the motors with less revs. Twin 225 mercs not working hard at all 24knots which is the most economical speed for this setup.  Certainly more in service costs etc but good piece of mind having 2 motors.

I guess as John has said all boats have some sort of compromise but i certainly dont regret getting a centre console.

(especially a whaler !!!!) happy and dry fishing to you both !!

 

 

JohnF's picture

Posts: 2836

Date Joined: 07/07/10

 - rides like a deep dead

Mon, 2016-04-11 19:51

 My perfect boat:

- rides like a deep dead rise regulator or contender going out  into chop

- handles a big following sea like a flatter v boat

- has the fuel economy of a Ali runaboit

- has the stability at rest of a shark cat

- has 4 berths for Rotto long weekends

- is enclosed for cold winters conditions

- is a centre console so I can fish all around the boat

- low cost to buy

Best you can usually do is get 3 or 4 of these in one boat  or get more but with compromises. 

The joys of boating!

-

 

 

 

 

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

Posts: 4577

Date Joined: 01/02/10

 Fast, cheap to run, good

Mon, 2016-04-11 20:03

 Fast, cheap to run, good ride. 

Choose 2

____________________________________________________________________________

Does anyone know where the love of god goes, when the waves turn the minutes to hours?

Bodie's picture

Posts: 3758

Date Joined: 05/11/07

 Here you go, Fury 282 Dual

Mon, 2016-04-11 21:14

 Here you go, Fury 282 Dual console

 

https://youtu.be/i2-tJBlk7WM

Dirt's picture

Posts: 463

Date Joined: 04/03/10

Carrabean/ Bertram 2300

Wed, 2016-04-13 16:41

I liked the new carrabean/ Bertram 2300, based on the old Bertram 23. Ive currently got the 21ft reef runner but this boat definately got my attention. More deck space, bigger dash for electronics, twice the fuel capacity at over 400ltrs and legal to tow. Yep this boat would do me nicely

Tim's picture

Posts: 2497

Date Joined: 26/09/06

2400

Wed, 2016-04-13 18:52

I like the 2400 but loaded its even too heavy for a cruiser.
2300 would do it for me too. Needs a mini tower to go with it.

Dirt's picture

Posts: 463

Date Joined: 04/03/10

Mini tower

Wed, 2016-04-13 19:11

 yep very nice, I've seen the 2400 with a mini collapsible tower fitted so I'm sure it wouldn't be a problem with the 2300. Best thing about the 23 and 24 is decent deck room in comparison to a lot of other boats

Posts: 388

Date Joined: 28/12/12

 The 2400 is what my dreams

Sat, 2016-04-16 00:46

 The 2400 is what my dreams are mate of epic boat

____________________________________________________________________________

 Pgfc member

JohnF's picture

Posts: 2836

Date Joined: 07/07/10

A mate just forwarded this

Tue, 2018-05-22 11:30

A mate just forwarded this old thread to me, which made me laugh, as I had actually forgotten about stepping onto the Regulator 23 CC over 2 years ago, but things have changed recently so worth a final note on this thread...... 

 

Back in 2016, I had basically decided my Boston Whaler 235 Conquest was as good a compromise boat as I could get for my purposes, and that has not changed.  Just back from another awesome Exxy trip with the boys and a recent trip to Rotto with the wife and young bloke and the Whaler was supurb at both. 

 

HOWEVER........an opportunity recently arose to go 1/3 ownership in a "deam boat" with 2 other mates.......we all ageeed to chuck in a chunk of hard earned....just needed to agree  on the dream boat.....After a world wide search of ALL and ANY type of boat......and after actually test dring the Regulaotr 23 (yep, everything I said 2 years ago was correct) and a Regulator 34 (wow), all 3 of us concluded the dream boat  for US was.......a Regulator 28 CC......

 

Beast of a boat, 32 ft overall length (28 is VERY conservative), 2 x 300 yammies, 52 knot top speed, absolutely top notch construction, uncompromising deep V fishing battleship! The Bugatti of the ocean. Downside is price (eyewatering) but this is mitigated by sharing the pain with 2 others which is surprisingly comforting......at worse, there are 2 other blokes as dumb as me!

 

Boat is being built to our spec in the good ol USA as we speak.....bring on September when it will hit WA! 

 

As for the Boston Whaler 235.........I was not keen to sell it but my wife had the last say.....and stated in no uncertain terms that we will be the keeping the Whaler regardless of any other "fishing" boat I may get. Yep....I chose both boat and wife well!!! 

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

Stevo81's picture

Posts: 1278

Date Joined: 16/04/12

I’ve been waiting for your

Tue, 2018-05-22 11:31

I’ve been waiting for your Regulator build thread to pop up mate! 

Are you buying a Dodge Ram to tow it with too or keeping it in the water? 

____________________________________________________________________________

                                   ••••••••  Electrical Contractor NOR  ••••••••

Posts: 577

Date Joined: 23/04/14

Very nice

Wed, 2018-05-23 05:58

 About a month ago I saw a Regulator on a beach mooring at Rotto, must have been at least 30’ (maybe a 28 with the bracket?), powered by 3x300 Yammies.

Actually now I think about it, might have been a 34, it was a big boat.

____________________________________________________________________________

 

 

JohnF's picture

Posts: 2836

Date Joined: 07/07/10

 The whole tow thing is in

Tue, 2018-05-22 11:35

 The whole tow thing is in the too hard basket in Oz given it will be over 5 t including trailer.......I think it will be a case of chucking it on the back of a semi and getting a truckie to drop it where we want it. 

____________________________________________________________________________

Boston Whaler 235 Conquest......getting the flogging it was built for.

ranmar850's picture

Posts: 2702

Date Joined: 12/08/12

probably the first tinnies made in Oz were rivetted

Tue, 2018-05-22 12:51

 Anyone remember the DeHavillands?  Yes the same Dehavilland Aircraft company, makers of some famous aircraft. they had excess workshop capacity at Bankstown and went into fabricating boats using their airframe fabrication expertise. The most famous one would have been the Trojan--22ft LOA IIRC, built like a tank, used by the miltary, police and civilian sea search and rescue. Australias very first big tinny. They lasted pretty well, but the rivetting usually let them down in the end. A mate had 14 footer with a 40 Evinrude pull start on the back, we dived the hell out of that. This was late sixties/early seventies, it was getting on 20 years old by then, and was a bit leaky. Some good quality tinnies still use rivetting for stuff above the water line like seat supports--much better for bonding a thin bracket to a hull than welding.

 

reading the above just reinforces that EVERY boat is a compromise, just pick what you are happy to be compromised on. I just laugh when someone states their boat is "No-compromise"

Posts: 4577

Date Joined: 01/02/10

 Funny you mention them. I

Tue, 2018-05-22 14:43

 Funny you mention them. I took the family down to a mates holiday house at horrocks for the school holidays and borrowed a 14ft riveted dehavilland. Didn’t leak at all and was a great tinny. 

____________________________________________________________________________

Does anyone know where the love of god goes, when the waves turn the minutes to hours?