I have a 2008 2102 Trophy hard top, awesome boat, rides well, nicely finished inside and out, reasonably light to tow, plenty of fuel (320L), does nearly 40 knots with a 175 Verado and has a good sized cabin. Only negatives are lacks a bit of deck space and could do with a little more storage.

I think the pre 2006 Trophy's were made under the Bayliner banner and lacked a bit of quality, after they stepped away from Bayliner and were built under the Brunswick name quality and finish got a lot better.

Would I buy another one? Definately, good value for money compared with some of the others. Can't comment on the Commodore or Mustang.

 I can't comment on the other two.

I have a 2006 2052 Trophy Pro. I reckon it is a great sea boat for it's size. Mine has the 120hp Diesel so it's no speed machine but I don't have to worry about running out of fuel doing day trips as it also has 320 litres. Could do with higher sides IMO. Really like the walkaround plenty of room, I am quite often up the front jigging.

Wouldn't mind a bit more Hp but it'll do me for a while.

Chris 

I have the commodore centre console 6.7m. Awesome fishing boat with plenty of deck space. Great hull. Old fraser mould. Rides very well. I know set up a little different on the cabin version but have fished from the 670 cabin & was impressed with stability. I guess depends on your uses. 

Happy hunting!

 Go with the one with the most deck space = commodore

Yeh depends on what you want to do. I had a Trophy and it was great!

I have a Commodore 680 allrounder with a ETECH 200hp. shite loads of fishing room, good size cab, could do with a bit more storage, or a kill tank.
Does 40knts by GPS speed. handles the chop brilliantly. would not pass this boat for another