Which 40hp 2st?

 I'm planning on upgrading the outboard on the tinnie from a 25, to a 40, she is a bit of a slug with 4 people on board. 

Ihave done the ring around and have got some prices, just wondering about if anyone has one, how it goes.

 

All looking at most basic 40, manual tilt, manual start, premix fuel.

Yamaha 2 cylinder 1 carb enduro $4500, 2 year warranty 

Suzuki 2 cylinder 1 carb $4000, 2 year warranty 

Mercury 3 cylinder 3 carb $4000, 5 year warranty. 

 

So the mercury is in the lead. 

 

My uncle in Guilderton has the Suzuki 30 with no problems in 2 years from new. 


Posts: 1101

Date Joined: 19/06/14

I'm a Yamaha man

Fri, 2015-01-30 20:03

 Yammie all the way any day.... From my first smoking two stoke motorbike 25 years ago I've always had some form of Yamaha motor in my care.Look after em PROPERLY and they'll never let you down.Next on the wish list is a four stroke 150 for my Huntriss project.

 

____________________________________________________________________________

 My wife understands why I clean my rods n reels in the shower....

 

hornet42's picture

Posts: 179

Date Joined: 24/07/12

Service cost

Fri, 2015-01-30 20:26

 Get a price on a service  then pick 

____________________________________________________________________________

 PB  Dhu  850 mm Pink 820mm 

Josh's picture

Posts: 281

Date Joined: 14/09/10

 Yamaha annual is

Sat, 2015-01-31 12:22

 Yamaha annual is 300-350 

Merc and zuke are 400-450

Posts: 315

Date Joined: 07/05/11

+1 yammie

Fri, 2015-01-30 21:56

 had a 2000 enduro60 Yamaha and loved it

just re powered mine at jet power- definitely will buy from them again

____________________________________________________________________________

 Baron Sportsman

Just the depth that Varies

Posts: 218

Date Joined: 15/01/10

 Yamaha then the Suzuki. I

Sat, 2015-01-31 10:07

 Yamaha then the Suzuki. I would stay clear of the Mercury. 

____________________________________________________________________________

null

kirky79's picture

Posts: 1351

Date Joined: 13/01/12

 I had a Mercury 40 hp on my

Sat, 2015-01-31 13:25

 I had a Mercury 40 hp on my last tinny and never had a problem with it. I was told but not sure that they were a Tohatsu rebadged as a Merc. Anyway just my experience. 

Chris

grantarctic1's picture

Posts: 2546

Date Joined: 03/03/11

15 years

Sat, 2015-01-31 14:35

Aprox 15 years ago i bought a second hand Tohatsu 30hp 2st with only 3 hours on it. I paid $2000 and repowered my old Clark 4.3 with it. I never serviced it for ten years only replacing the plugs as needed. Altho not recomended it worked out to cost me aprox $200 per year of use and i had no problems at all untill i sold it and had it serviced first. Then the coil pack cracked.

To get a new coil and fitted with a service the price quoted was half the price of a brand new motor, So my friend who bought it opted for a new motor and after many quotes he got the same motor new (Tohatsu 30 2st ) for $3200 in late 2013. Very happy with the motor, fuel use was halved and i'm glad to say he gets it serviced every 100 hours.

I researched it for him and found the 40hp was quite a bit more in price than the 30. I was told they only make the 40 because some hulls rate that size as max hp, and it is actually a 50hp motor with a reduced exhaust system and smaller carby. Thats why they are not much cheaper than the 50hp.

As Chris says, lots of motor brand use the same engine blocks, heads and other parts. When you google parts for a Tohatsu you will find most of them listed as Nissan as with quite a few other brands.

In the end we went with Tohatsu because the 30hp came in a long leg for no extra price. It also had electric start and a will send current back to charge your batteries. Othe brands did not offer this and were between $200 and $800 more expensive.

Just my expirence and others will prefer different brands. I know most guys with Yammy's are happy with thier choice, and same with modern Suzuki owners.

MandurahMatt's picture

Posts: 613

Date Joined: 18/09/13

i got a 2007 40 Suzy it

Mon, 2015-02-02 03:03

i got a 2007 40 Suzy it hasent skipped a beat, not that ive had the other two to compare it to, but i dont think its very fuel efficent. not sure on above servicing costs. think i paid under $200 last time i had it serviced.

____________________________________________________________________________

 Bewdey Fellaz

Beerburper's picture

Posts: 55

Date Joined: 02/01/13

 I've got a 2012 yammie 40

Tue, 2015-02-03 17:48

 I've got a 2012 yammie 40 enduro, absolute beauty runs smooth and cheap to service. Very hard to go past I think.

____________________________________________________________________________

 It's not about the getting, it's about the doing.

 

Beerburper's picture

Posts: 55

Date Joined: 02/01/13

 I've got a 2012 yammie 40

Tue, 2015-02-03 17:48

 I've got a 2012 yammie 40 enduro, absolute beauty runs smooth and cheap to service. Very hard to go past I think.

____________________________________________________________________________

 It's not about the getting, it's about the doing.

 

Posts: 21

Date Joined: 22/03/12

yammie or merc for me, id stay away from the suzi.

Tue, 2015-02-03 18:55

 with proper maintenance they should all give you hours of happy days 

Paul_86's picture

Posts: 1449

Date Joined: 27/03/09

 Can you elaborate on "stay

Tue, 2015-02-03 22:40

 Can you elaborate on "stay away from Suzuki"? Gotta say I havnt seen a statement like that against modern Suzuki outboards before!!!

Posts: 21

Date Joined: 22/03/12

 Mate bought a 40HP suzi off

Wed, 2015-02-04 18:17

 Mate bought a 40HP suzi off the showroom floor, been nothing but trouble. Within 30hrs it was making a loud pinging sound. Returned to the dealer who replaced the the engine block , still has the same issue. It has compression problems and spent more time in the shop than on the water. I dont doubt its an isolated issue and simply got a 'lemon' but i would opt for either Merc or Yammie purely based on his experience hence the quote 'I'D stay away from suzi'.